I love coming up with new drinks that remind me of my favorite desserts. The Rumchata Sweet Potato Pie Cocktail tastes like a creamy slice of sweet potato pie, but in a glass.

It brings together the warm spices of sweet potato and that smooth, cinnamon flavor from Rumchata. This drink is quick and easy to make at home.

Honestly, it’s great for sharing during the holidays or whenever I want something comforting that feels a little special.

Rumchata Sweet Potato Pie Cocktail Recipe

This drink combines the smooth taste of Rumchata with the cozy flavors of sweet potato, cinnamon, and vanilla. I like to keep things simple—easy tools, easy ingredients, and steps that don’t make me feel like I’m running a bar.

John

Prep Time 5

Total Time 5

Serving Size

Equipment

A shaker is pretty important for mixing the Rumchata, sweet potato puree, and the rest until it’s nice and smooth.
I use a strainer to catch any pulp or ice before pouring.
Measuring tools like a jigger or even just a small measuring cup help me get the right amounts.

Sometimes I want the drink extra smooth, so I’ll use a fine mesh sieve.
Glassware matters too—I usually pour this into a rocks or martini glass.
And, if I’m feeling a little fancy, I keep a bar spoon nearby for stirring,

A vegetable peeler to make cinnamon or nutmeg shavings for garnish.

Ingredients

I stick to a short ingredient list for this one. Here’s what I use:

Rumchata 2 oz
Sweet Potato Puree 1 oz
Vanilla Vodka 1 oz
Maple Syrup optional ½ oz
Ground Cinnamon 1 pinch
Ice For shaking
Whipped Cream optional For topping
Nutmeg or Cinnamon Stick For garnish

Instructions

First, I fill my shaker with ice. Then I add Rumchata, sweet potato puree, vanilla vodka, maple syrup, and a pinch of cinnamon.
I shake it up hard for about 20 seconds, just until it’s cold and everything’s mixed. Next, I strain the mixture into a glass—sometimes through a fine mesh strainer if I want it super smooth.
Every now and then, I’ll add whipped cream on top and finish with a dusting of nutmeg or maybe a cinnamon stick for garnish. I drink it right away while it’s cold and creamy.

This recipe makes one serving. If I’m making drinks for friends, doubling it is no big deal.

Notes

Sweet potato gives this drink a unique flavor and creamy texture. I always make sure the puree is blended really well so I don’t get any weird lumps.

If it ends up too thick, I’ll splash in a bit of milk to thin it out. This cocktail is rich, so I usually save it for dessert or when I want something indulgent.

If I’m in the mood for something lighter, I just use less sweet potato or maple syrup. Sometimes I blend and strain the mix ahead of time, then just shake it with ice when I’m ready to serve.

Garnishes like whipped cream, nutmeg, or a cinnamon stick are totally optional, but they make the drink look and taste a little more special. I always serve it chilled, never over ice, so it keeps that creamy look and feel.

Tasting Notes

When I sip the Rumchata Sweet Potato Pie Cocktail, the first thing that hits me is the creamy texture. It almost feels like drinking dessert.

I get warm cinnamon and nutmeg right away—just like homemade sweet potato pie. The Rumchata adds a light vanilla flavor and a little hint of rum.

The sweet potato brings in this earthy sweetness. It balances with the dairy and spice, so it never feels too sugary or heavy.

Key flavors I notice:

Sweet potato
Cinnamon
Nutmeg
Vanilla
Light rum

I pick up a smooth finish, too. The flavors hang around for a bit, but there’s no harsh alcohol burn.

It’s definitely best served cold—makes every sip feel extra refreshing. If you ask me, this cocktail is basically dessert in a glass: sweet, creamy, and really easy to enjoy.

Substitute

Sometimes I just don’t have every ingredient for the Rumchata Sweet Potato Pie Cocktail. Other times, I’m in the mood to switch things up and see what happens.

Here are a few ways I’ve swapped out ingredients over time.

Rumchata Substitute Options:

Baileys Irish Cream: It’s creamy and sweet, though the flavor’s definitely not quite the same.
Horchata and Rum: Mix these together and you get something pretty close, honestly.
Homemade cinnamon cream liqueur: If I’m feeling ambitious, I’ll mix milk, cinnamon, and rum. Works as a quick fix.

If I’m out of whipped cream, I’ll sometimes just use marshmallow fluff. Or even plain vanilla yogurt—both work for a creamy topping in a pinch.

When I want it non-alcoholic, I go with cinnamon milk and a spoonful of sweet potato or pumpkin puree. Still tastes smooth and sweet, and nobody’s missing out.

I do a quick taste test before mixing, since some substitutes end up way sweeter or thicker than you’d expect.

Rumchata Sweet Potato Pie Cocktail Recipe