Add bourbon, maple syrup, apple cider, lemon juice, orange juice, bitters, and vanilla to a mixing pitcher or punch bowl.
Add cinnamon stick, nutmeg, and star anise.
Stir until well combined.
Fill glasses with ice and pour punch over ice, straining out spices if desired.
Top with club soda or ginger beer if desired.
Garnish with lemon wheels, orange slices, rosemary, or cinnamon stick.
Serve immediately and refrigerate any leftovers.
Notes
Always use pure maple syrup for best flavor. Fresh-squeezed lemon juice keeps the punch bright. Adjust sweetness or spice to taste. Add club soda for a lighter version or sparkling cider for extra festivity.