Use your favorite bourbon—smoother is better. Adjust maple syrup to taste. Chill all ingredients before mixing for the coldest punch. Omit bourbon for a non-alcoholic version and add extra cider (a splash of orange juice is nice). Club soda adds fizz, but it’s delicious without. Fresh apple cider is best for big flavor. Try a pinch of nutmeg or a cinnamon stick for more autumn spice!