Smoke & Fire Scotch Sour Cocktail Recipe

ByJohn

I’ve always loved messing with classic drinks, and honestly, the Smoke & Fire Scotch Sour is near the top of my list. There’s something about that smoky scotch, the tartness of lemon, and just enough sweetness—it really hits the spot if you’re into bold, smoked cocktails.

This recipe lets me whip up a unique, impressive sour at home—even if I’ve never tried making smoked cocktails before. With just a handful of ingredients and simple steps, I can pull off a drink that looks and tastes like it should cost $18 at a fancy bar.

I’ll walk through what you need, how to make it, and a few little tricks so anyone can enjoy this smoky scotch sour. No need for fancy gear or bartending skills.

Smoke & Fire Scotch Sour Cocktail Recipe

Smoke & Fire Scotch Sour Cocktail Recipe

This Smoke & Fire Scotch Sour is all about smoky, tart flavors coming together in a pretty striking cocktail. Scotch, citrus, and some creative garnishes give it a twist that’s hard to forget.

Equipment

  • Cocktail shaker: I use this to mix everything quickly and get the drink nice and cold.
  • Jigger or shot glass: For measuring out the scotch, simple syrup, and citrus juices.
  • Strainer: Helps keep ice and herbs out of the finished drink.
  • Rocks glass: I like a glass that feels solid in my hand.
  • Bar spoon: Handy for stirring, especially if I want to layer bitters or float something on top.
  • Smoking gun or lighter (optional): If I’m feeling dramatic, I’ll use a smoking gadget. Cherry wood or applewood chips both work.
  • Citrus juicer: Fresh lemon and lime juice just taste better, and it’s less wasteful.
  • Small torch or lighter: For lighting rosemary as a smoky garnish.

Ingredients

Instructions

  • Add lemon juice, lime juice, simple syrup, scotch, mezcal, bitters, and aquafaba to a shaker.
  • Fill it up with ice.
  • Shake hard for about 10–15 seconds; you want it cold and frothy.
  • Strain into a rocks glass with fresh ice.
  • Use a smoking gun or torch to smoke a rosemary sprig. I usually hold the smoking rosemary over the glass for a bit of drama, or sometimes I’ll smoke the glass itself before pouring.
  • Garnish with the smoked rosemary and a cherry on a cocktail pick.
  • If you want even more smoke, flame a wood chip under an inverted glass or add the tiniest drop of liquid smoke.

Notes

Scotch and mezcal bring their own smoky vibes—scotch is more earthy, mezcal is almost like a campfire. If mezcal’s not around, liquid smoke works, but honestly, go easy—a drop or two is plenty. For a tarter drink, I’ll add extra lemon or lime.

Aquafaba (yep, chickpea liquid) is a solid vegan swap for egg white. Chilling the glass first keeps things colder, longer.

A torched rosemary sprig smells amazing and adds something special, almost theatrical. Smoked cherries are easy—just hit canned cherries with a smoking gun for a minute or two. If you want more spice, try chili bitters; angostura is more classic. I always end up tweaking the smoke or citrus depending on my mood.

Smoke & Fire Scotch Sour Cocktail Recipe

Smoke & Fire Scotch Sour Cocktail Recipe
This bold and smoky twist on a classic sour blends scotch, citrus, and bitters with a touch of fire—from mezcal or rosemary smoke. It’s smooth, tart, aromatic, and always makes an impression.
John
Prep Time 5 minutes
Total Time 5 minutes
Serving Size 1 Cocktail

Equipment

Ingredients

Instructions

  • Add scotch, mezcal, lemon juice, lime juice, simple syrup, bitters, and aquafaba to a shaker.
  • Fill the shaker with ice cubes and shake hard for 10–15 seconds.
  • Strain into a rocks glass filled with fresh ice.
  • Use a torch or smoking gun to light or smoke a rosemary sprig. Hover the smoking rosemary over the glass or smoke the glass before pouring.
  • Garnish with the rosemary sprig and a cocktail cherry on a pick.
  • Optional: smoke the drink further with wood chips or add a drop of liquid smoke for intensity.

Tasting Notes

First sip? There’s this bold, smoky aroma that hits right away. The scotch gives off that lingering, campfire scent—kind of nostalgic, honestly.

The taste is tart but smooth. Lemon brings a nice tang, and it balances with the rich scotch.

It’s not too sweet, which I love.

If I’ve added spicy syrup or bitters, there’s a gentle heat at the end—not overwhelming, just a warm little kick.

Here’s what stands out for me:

  • Aroma: Smoky, a bit earthy
  • First Sip: Lemon tang, soft sweetness
  • Mid-Palate: More smoke, gentle honey or sugar
  • Finish: Warm, spicy hint that lingers

I like how the smoke, citrus, and warmth all play off each other. It’s balanced, never too much of one thing. I usually find myself wanting another sip, just to see how it changes as the ice melts.

Must Have Ingredients

Substitute

Sometimes I’m missing an ingredient or two for the Smoke & Fire Scotch Sour, so I end up improvising. Substitutes can totally save the day, and honestly, sometimes I even like the new version better.

Whiskey Substitutes:

  • If I’m out of smoky Scotch, I’ll grab a Smoked Manhattan or Smoked Old Fashioned as the base instead.
  • Bourbon works too—sure, it’s not smoky, but it brings its own charm.

Citrus or Sweetener:

  • Maple syrup instead of simple syrup? It’s richer, a little earthier, and I’m a fan.
  • If I want to skip syrup altogether, sweet vermouth steps in and adds some depth.

Citrus Liqueur Options:

  • Cointreau sometimes makes its way in for a brighter note, especially if I’m out of lemon.

Other Smoked Cocktail Inspirations:

  • Drinks like Smoked Margarita, Smoked Margarita Sour, or even a Smoked Bloody Mary get me thinking—why not try smoking the citrus or syrup for this recipe, too?
  • Blackberry Whiskey Sour is another fun twist; muddled blackberries give it a fruity punch.

Savory or Spicy Touches:

  • Every now and then, I’ll toss in a bit of smoked bacon for something savory.
  • If I’m feeling bold, a pinch of chili or a sprinkle of smoked salt (inspired by the Smoke and Spice Old Fashioned) adds a nice kick.

Equipment to Try:

Ingredients You Can Substitute:

Instructions for Substitution:

  • Pick your base spirit—Scotch, bourbon, whatever’s handy.
  • Mix it up with your preferred syrup (simple or maple) and a splash of citrus.
  • Want more flavor? Go ahead and add vermouth, Cointreau, or even muddled berries.
  • Shake it well, strain over ice, and finish with whatever creative garnish you’re in the mood for.

Hey there, I’m John Watson—a guy who’s spent over 20 years proving that a good drink can fix just about anything (well, almost anything). Whether it’s cocktails that wow or mocktails that mock boredom, I’m all about crafting sips with stories. Founder of ThirstyTales and full-time drink nerd, I’m here to help you shake things up, one glass at a time. Let’s mix, laugh, and maybe spill a little—cheers to the adventure!

Similar Posts

  • |

    Mint Julep Mixer Cocktail Recipe

  • |

    Fireball Cinnamon Whiskey Eggnog Cocktail Recipe

  • |

    Bourbon Cinnamon Hot Toddy Cocktail Recipe

  • |

    Bourbon Chocolate Mint Cocktail Recipe

  • |

    Honey Walnut Whiskey Sour Cocktail Recipe

  • |

    Rum Sour with a Halloween Twist Cocktail Recipe

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating