Bourbon Hot Toddy Cocktail Recipe

When the weather turns cold, I always reach for a drink that feels warm and comforting. A Bourbon Hot Toddy does exactly that with simple ingredients and a smooth flavor that’s just easy to enjoy.

This classic cocktail brings together bourbon, hot water, citrus, and a touch of sweetness for a drink that’s both soothing and flavorful.

I like how it stands apart from mulled wine or other warm cocktails—it’s lighter, less spiced, but still has character. The mix of bourbon with fresh lime or lemon keeps it balanced and refreshing, not heavy.

If you’re after a new cocktail recipe or just want something cozy to sip on a cool night, this one’s easy to make and worth a try. It’s simple, classic, and honestly, always satisfying.

Bourbon Hot Toddy Cocktail Recipe

I make a bourbon hot toddy when I want something warm, simple, and soothing. It’s really just bourbon, hot water, lemon, and honey, with a few spices or a nice garnish if I’m feeling fancy.

Equipment

• Heatproof mug or glass – I grab a sturdy mug that keeps the drink hot but doesn’t burn my hands.
• Kettle or small pot – I use this to heat up water, tea, or cider.
• Teaspoon – Good for stirring honey and mixing in the lemon juice.
• Citrus juicer or reamer – This saves my hands when squeezing fresh lemon.
• Knife and cutting board – For slicing lemon or orange for garnish.
• Measuring jigger – Makes it easy to pour the right amount of bourbon.
• Optional strainer – Handy if I decide to add whole spices like cloves or star anise.

Ingredients

• 2 oz bourbon whiskey (or rye whiskey, rum, or brandy)
• 3/4 oz fresh lemon juice
• 2–3 tsp honey or pure maple syrup
• 4–6 oz hot water, black tea, or hot apple cider
• 1 lemon slice or orange wheel for garnish
• 1 cinnamon stick
• 2–3 whole cloves or 1 star anise (optional)
• Extra spices like nutmeg or allspice if I want more depth

I usually stick with honey for that classic flavor, but sometimes maple syrup just hits differently and adds a richer taste. Hot tea or cider as a base makes the drink feel a bit more filling.

Instructions

• Heat water, tea, or cider until it’s steaming, not quite boiling.
• Add honey or maple syrup to the mug.
• Pour in the hot liquid and stir until the sweetener dissolves.
• Squeeze in fresh lemon juice.
• Add bourbon and stir gently.
• Garnish with a lemon slice, orange wheel, or cinnamon stick.
• Drop in cloves or star anise if I’m in the mood for more spice.

I always taste as I go, tweaking the sweetness or lemon to get the balance right.

Notes

Sometimes I swap bourbon for rye whiskey when I want a little more bite. Rum or brandy makes the drink smoother and sweeter, which is nice if I’m in the mood for something softer.

Hot apple cider instead of water? That gives it a fall vibe, especially with cinnamon and cloves. For a lighter touch, I’ll use black tea as the base.

A cinnamon stick works as a stirrer, and whole cloves add aroma without taking over the drink. I avoid boiling water because it turns the lemon bitter—trust me, not great.

This drink’s best when served right away, piping hot. If I’m making a few, I keep the water hot in a kettle and mix each one fresh.

Tasting Notes

When I take the first sip, the bourbon really jumps out with its warm, smooth flavor. There’s this gentle sweetness that just hangs out with the honey.

The heat from the hot water makes it feel like a proper winter drink—seriously, it’s comforting.

I catch a light spice from the clove and cinnamon. These spices don’t take over, but they give the drink a cozy kind of depth.

The lemon shows up with a fresh, bright note, and it cuts through the richness of the bourbon.

The texture comes across soft and soothing. Honey leaves a slight coating on my tongue, but the citrus keeps it from getting too heavy.

I love how the aroma lines up with the flavor. The steam brings hints of vanilla, oak, and spice right to my nose before I even taste it.

Flavor highlights I pick up:

• Warm vanilla and oak from the bourbon
• Sweetness from the honey
• Bright citrus from the lemon
• Gentle spice from clove and cinnamon

Every sip feels calm and steady. It’s honestly perfect for sipping slow on a cold evening.